19 February, 2010

Planes, Trains, and Automobiles

 
[via wikipedia]

"Can you wait three minutes?"

This question was posed to me while ordering my dinner from a restaurant in Arlington, Virginia. It was near closing time, and the cooks had begun cleaning up, so my order of fries was going to take a few minutes before they would be ready. The restaurant was surprisingly busy for this late on a Monday night, but I reasoned that the massive accumulation of snow outside had not just canceled my train home, it had also shut down streets, grocery stores, and restaurants across the entire region.

I had prepared myself for a quick, three-day trip to Washington, DC to interview with a few firms. When one interviewer asked me if I would be able to meet with another person on Monday (the person I would be working more directly with) I reluctantly agreed. This was Super Bowl Weekend, and I was planning on hosting a party on Sunday night. But if the extra time would help me land the job, I was willing to stay. The Super Bowl was not my only reason for wanting to leave on time - the snow was just beginning to fall, and many business had already closed in anticipation of the snow. My lack of understanding just what was about to take place was underscored by the comment I made to the interviewer:

"You know what we call this in Chicago?"
"What's that?"
"June"

The snows began on Saturday. On Sunday the skies parted and cabin-fevered Washingtonians began to take to the street. The street scene was one I truly enjoyed seeing; the streets were hardly plowed, to say nothing of the sidewalks, and there were few vehicles out. In their stead, throngs of people could be seen walking up and down the newly pedestrianized streets amidst the winter wonderland. The collective need surpassed our selfishness, and people could be seen digging out sidewalks, removing snow from a neighbors' roof, or pushing a car out of a snow-fortified parking space. It was a stunning moment of humanity in which I saw the possibilities of a pedestrianized world and the potential of all the networks and relationships that could be forged when we no longer passed by each other at 40 miles an hour, but had time to wave, say "hi", and ask how a strangers' day has been going. I wish I would have had my camera.

After I found out I was going to be staying until Monday, I traded my Saturday train ticket for one on Tuesday morning. This was a simple process, and I applaud Amtrak for its ease. But neither train was to leave; both were canceled, logically, due to the heavy amounts of snow accumulation strung between DC and Chicago. If the trip is normally 17 hours, imagine that same trip plowing through 26 inches of snow. I rescheduled again, this time for Wednesday. It was also at this time that I booked a cheap flight out of Dulles. While I was glad to be arriving in Chicago 36 hours earlier than I would have on Amtrak, I was slightly disappointed that I couldn't complete my round-trip journey by train alone. 

Tuesday's blizzard only compounded the problems. In addition to the trains not running, the airports had closed indefinitely, and me without a car, was stuck there to wait it out. I knew beforehand that America had a love affair with cars, but I've always been biased toward mass transit, and so I could overlook its deficiencies. But stranded in DC with no way of leaving, no way to get around, I was given no choice but to come to grips with the fact that America NEEDS cars. Yes, we can build a national high-speed rail network, and it will increase usage over today's ridership, but America came into its own during the automobile revolution, and as a result we have larger, more spread out cities in varied locations with little option to connect it all with any type of mass transit. Short of dynamiting each American city and starting from scratch, America will require a lot of cars.

And the cars we need do not need to look like the cars we have. Smaller, more efficient cars, cars that stack or compact, cars made for one or two people, cars that include towing or carrying capacity. Wind-, Solar-, and Geothermal-generated Hydrogen or electric cars can replace the internal combustion engine. Carpooling, rideshare, rentals, all are potential avenues for the new automobile. As my 4 canceled trains and 3 flights indicate, cars will be necessary.

And like most Earth-saving technologies, the market, policies, financing, technologies, or innovations are preventing them from hitting the streets today. So we should work toward many solutions, generating them in myriad ways, the same way one of my myriad schemes to get home finally panned out. Because some technologies will sputter out and some will be canceled, but given enough time one will carry us home.

So can I wait 3 minutes? You bet.

02 February, 2010

High-Speed Rail in America

This week I will be taking a 17 hour journey by train from Chicago to our nations' capital. I'm quite excited, as this will be my very first cross-country trip via Amtrak. Moreover, I am very pleased that I will be able to go from my house to Union Station to Washington DC, to Silver Spring, MD, to Bethesda, MD, back to DC, then to Chicago, and back to my front door, all without setting foot in a single car. The trip will span 5 states, involve 3 mass transit systems, and will include an estimated 40 hours on one for of train or another. Needless to say, I'm taking a few books.

What I find amazing about all of this is that someone like myself - a confessed TrainGeek and mobility infrastructure wonk - has yet in my life embarked on such a journey. I've taken similar routes in Europe, where I traveled from the small village of Didcot in England, to within 200' of my apartment in Paris. Of course that trip utilised Europes' high-speed rail connections, and which saw me across four train systems and two countries, all in about 6 hours. But this trip on Amtrak is quite different. Amtrak is a notoriously slow and unreliable service. In its entire history it has failed to turn a single year of profit, and thus relies heavily on government subsidies. I nearly opted against this excursion on Amtrak, as the total travel time will nearly double, and the cost is slightly higher than would be the cost of gas for the trip. The only reason I'm willing to make these concessions is that I don't like driving, and I do like the free time granted by rail travel. Indeed if I weren't such a geek about trains, there is little chance I would not have driven my car all that way. Unfortunately for Amtrak, there are few people like myself that are willing to make such concessions.

And thus the great American High-Speed Rail Gamble: Obama is putting a great deal of money on the line that if given the choice between driving or flying, or having the option to travel on relatively inexpensive, reliable, safe, and convenient high-speed rail, that Americans will choose the latter. Even with my obvious biases toward rail (I would love to visit any medium-sized metropolitan city without setting foot in a car), I do feel that this is a realistic and as-of-yet unresolved issue. To provide high-speed rail in the quantity and quality required to turn a profit, costs may end up being prohibitive to flying. If you seek to provide cheap, reliable service you will end up sacrificing quality.
And so on.

Therefore I hold the belief that if you are to provide the type of service, quality, etc, required to convince people that rail is a viable option, AND you provide it at a cost similar to or less than driving, you must first revolutionize the way we think about "high-speed rail" I do not believe that the European or Asian models will work in America. This is what I think will:

Dedicated, elevated rail: Amtrak faces its sloth and inconsistency on two factors: 1)They share rail lines with freight trains, and often are the second-priority when it comes to sharing a single track. This results in increased stoppage time, and when they can run,  2) track quality, contextual issues, and imposed speed regulations prevent the trains from achieving a speed necessary to provide quick transit. By providing dedicated tracks the trains will be able to travel smoothly and consistently. By elevating the track, the risk of animals or debris on the tracks is reduced and speeds can be increased.

Electrified rail: The second advantage to elevated rail is that the system can be provided ample, secure electricity to power the trains. This can also lead to cleaner transit if the power is generated sustainably.

Solar Power: With over 87 million square feet of potential surface area along the rail between Chicago and DC, there's ample opportunity to install solar panels along many different lengths. The panels would have direct access to sunlight, and would be able to easily power the entire rail system, thus providing clean, cheap energy. There's potential for additional profit if Amtrak sells power back to the grid when not in use.


Computerized trains: Having studied the CTA budget, it's plain to see that the highest cost to any mass transit program is its manpower. While I would certainly never suggest fully automating a 200 MPH train with hundreds of live aboard, there's certainly an ability to automate many functions of rail travel, which reduces costs and reduces the risk of human error. One engineer aboard a bullet train could pilot the vehicle, while the computer monitors the engines, the passenger cars, and the track ahead. Automating certain aspects of the stations would further prohibit human error and improve safety. Maintenance of tracks and vehicles would be much more efficient if the tracks and vehicles were monitoring themselves and pointing mechanics to specific issues, instead of lengthy and costly maintenance overhauls on healthy trains.

Smart Ticketing: The ability exists today to implement a ticketing system that would provide any industry (airlines, hotels, sports venues, etc) with the right balance of occupancy and profit. Creating a program that analyzes trends in hourly, daily, monthly, yearly, and 5-year purchasing, companies could simply input their desired occupancy (75% full, 95% full, etc.) and the program would constantly adjust prices so that the cost rises when demand rises and lowers when demand lowers. As the scheduled departure approaches ticket prices would increase or decrease dramatically in order to fill the requisite seats. This system could be a boon to business class and other last-minute travelers, as they will be able to find inexpensive seats (as opposed to astronomical airline prices) and the train is able to make a bit more money by filling up the last remaining seats.

These are a few. I'm sure I'll add to this list upon my return.

20 January, 2010

The Land of the Rings















Artist Roy Prol take a look at Earth if it had the rings of Saturn.

13 January, 2010

Of Millenia and Mirrors

One simply does not study under the tutelage of one Professor Waldman without an appreciation for mirrors, specifically mirrors which reflect alternate realities, passageways, and other immaterial ephemera. So when Roosevelt University announces plans to construct a new building along South Michigan, I cannot but see the bi-colored and reflective glass as a large mirror, reflecting the city and heavens.

So what is the effect of such reflected glazing (referred to as "mirrors") on the city, and what does it say about the architecture it envelopes? In the mid-century, modernists were using glass in part for the purpose of mirroring the external world. Examples like Lever House and the Hancock Building used glass to immaterialize their buildings - by cladding the structure in mirrors, one could create the effect of transparency, the irony being they were so opaque one could not see 3/8" past the surface.

This implication is perhaps more revelatory than simply playing with reflections. Mirrors used to disguise the true shape of a building, or employed to visually trick the onlooker into believing the building is smaller implies an apologetic demeanor, as if to offer a feeble mea culpa to the surrounding urbanism for such an obviously intrusive and incongruous bit of fabric. If there is any merit to this argument (and a quick look at some of the early mirrored buildings finds a pattern of incongruity with their fabric), then one might argue that buildings (or their architects) are self-aware - and self-conscious. Look at high-rises and skyscrapers built in the last 15 years, and the self-conscious apologetics of mirrored glass disappear. In their wake are buildings that stand tall and proud, determined to make a statement of themselves amongst the milieu of other tall buildings (see aqua tower). However, one key element has changed - the height of the surrounding urbanism. No longer are these tall buildings the pioneers of their locations. Unless a building is going exceedingly tall, there is no longer an incongruity of urbanism, and tall buildings are allowed to flaunt thier style with reckless inhibition. Even amongst the tallest buildings, there are examples of a mixture of attitudes toward environments; Burj Dubai stands alone within its context. It's clad in mirrors yes, but its shape and the curvature of the glass minimizes the effects of mirroring, and the building is allowed to stand alone. Trump Tower in Chicago is a second example. This building (some have speculated its role as a precursor to the burj dubai, given a similar structural language and both designed by Adrian Smith at SOM) begins to mirror its surroundings and the sky, minimizing its impact on the landscape.Although located along the Chicago River just north of the loop, it breaks away from the other tall buildings of the city and stands alone, an effect exaggerated when approaching the city some 10-20 miles out. The Spire offers another example, as does the now-underway Freedom Tower in New York City, which perhaps does the best job of treading a fine line between apologetic mirroring and brazen statement.

No doubt there are other interpretations of mirrors and buildings. I would like to revisit the use of mirrors on many of the structures around Millenium park, from the Pritzker Pavilion to the Bean, to the mirrors found on the wet pavement at Crown Fountain. This picture begins to hint at the phenomenal possibilities of mirrors which provide a glimpse of another world beyond. Such an idea is not to be found in many of the mirrored buildings we see today, that try to hide themselves from view. Instead mirrors to the moon provide visual access to exciting alternatives, which can truly be experienced at eye-level.
[via rjseg1]


05 January, 2010

Good Grief.


Last week I took the El down to Belmont and made the short trip to Intelligentsia Cafe. I enjoy their coffee and an occasional baked good, and as there are always a few open seats I stay a while and read or sketch. I also enjoy the Lakeview neighborhood.

I believe that my mind is naturally tuned to "Good" places. I define "Good" as places that have many of the devices that make places livable, interesting, engaging, and livable. These are the neighborhoods that are always lively and filled with activity, the places one goes if they wish to people-watch, or are just out for the evening without plans to see a movie, play, concert, or other form of entertainment. Good places are entertainment. But they are so much more, and what they are changes from year to year, season to season, even hour to hour. Many people like Good places, and they flock to them for many reasons. I am trying to understand those reasons, and what effect the built environment has on the making of Good places.

I believe that the Lakeview neighborhood, specifically the Broadway-Halsted corridor between Addison and Diversey, is a Good place. Rather, they are made up of several Good places, placed in a line and connected by short lengths of less-good places. As a result much of my thinking on what makes Good places comes from the 5-10 minute walk between the El stop and the Coffee Shop. This is by NO means the best or only Good place in Chicago, but given the frequency of my trips for caffeine, I have certainly developed a bias.

My quest to find Good places has been going on for years, in one way or another. While I was studying in Paris, the purpose of my entire fellowship was to form a pattern-book of sorts, but over the length of my time in Paris, I came to realize that cities as a whole are much more nebulous; that Paris, or Venice, or Las Vegas, or Kandy, Sri Lanka, or New Orleans, or Chicago, do not have a singular language or set of patterns that make them Good. Each of them follows certain a certain dictum of form, space, and hierarchy, but these in and of themselves do not guarantee Good places. The answer is nebulous.

So I offer a change of direction. Instead of Good places, let's look at Good spaces. This is the built environment; the making of space, the articulation of edges, and the ephemeral thickness that exists between them. A scaffolding for Good places.

29 December, 2009

Power Drive



If, like myself and 30% of the rest of America, you found yourself taking to the roads this holiday season, there's good chance you were cruising along some of the 46,876 miles of interstate spread across the country. I found myself taking an afternoon jaunt on I-39 between Chicago and St. Louis, and just as the last daylight was fading, came across the Mendota Hills Wind Farm. At just under 52 MW of total generating power its not the most powerful wind farm, but its proximity to the interstate and the sweeping vistas offered by glacial-flat farmland is enough to satisfy the infrastructure geek in me.



It amazes me that people still oppose these things. Seeing them spread across the fields like quiet sentinels, their power appreciated when comparing their size to the speed of the blades. Considering how little space they take up (compared to, say, solar) they really work well in agricultural settings. I can see how they may be considered an eyesore, but to me they are the true model of progress; free fuel from the earth, with no emissions, no sending our money to other countries... this is national security, plain and simple.

And it was that thought that piqued my interest. Here I was, gliding along a 240-mile stretch of highway that unarguably has had a major impact on the shaping of cities, a nation, and even an economy, and it was all justified as a national security measure. When Eisenhower proposed the Interstate System he billed it as necessary for the country to be able to mobilize the military and evacuate cities, and even for landing aircaft; the network mandates a certain proportion of straight, flat, clear stretches of highway to be used as emergency airstrips.

60 years later we are faced with a similar need for national security, only this time its energy security. President Obama's Stimulus spending provides funds (and not enough, in my opinion) for creating renewable power generation. Given the partisan fight that raged in DC during the creation of the bill, I do not believe that the need for renewable energy was framed enough as a national security measure; instead it continued to be framed as a global climate change issue, something that can (unfortunately) be made a political issue. Had the Obama Administration simply come out and say "Global climate change or not, this is good for the energy independence of America", it might have been passed with much broader support. But enough of my soapbox.


 [image: 63 Turbines of the Mendota Hills Wind Farm]

I'm more interested in the application. I've always been intrigued by the highway median: the long, narrow strip of no-mans land which finds its way from major city to major city, a permanent easement whose use would hinder no privately held land. I'd like to put a high-speed rail there. Or local trains. I'd like to cover it with solar panels or line it with fiber-optics, or even fill it with our trash, at once creating a natural barrier between oncoming traffic and taking us to task for our wasteful habits. Now add one more ingredient to my median-infrastructure soup: Wind Power.



Not only an amusing way to combat Highway Hypnosis (watching turbines rotate is much like watching a campfire, or ocean waves, its quite mesmerizing), the turbines would also provide critical locally-generated power where it is needed most. Even placing turbines only at overpasses would minimize power generation, as one can assume whenever overpasses are near, homes and towns cannot be too far beyond. And locally-produced power would more than make up the deficit caused by line loss when transmitting to the few and far-between agricultural consumers. Placing only at overpasses would also keep intact the lengths of highway/airstrip that helped generate support of the initial projects.

The only thing that could make it better is if enough turbines could be placed to power a high-speed mag-lev train in the median, and thus scratching one thing off my infrastructural Christmas list.

22 December, 2009

Immaterial Spaces



I came across an interesting experiment by Timo Arnall and Einar Sneve Martinussen from AHO and Jack Schulze from BERG, in which they mapped the space created by waves emitted from RFID chips. By creating a rig that would trigger an LED each time it entered the RFID field, and capturing these moments on time-lapse photographs, the team was able to create 2-D images of the field. Then, by sequencing the 2-D images in a series of slice, created a 3-dimensional representation of the field. Video here.

 The fields being given off by many different technologies, from microwave ovens to CTA cards, to Wi-Fi hubs and radio stations, can each be spatially mapped to understand their limitations. Mapping an "immaterial space" can have enormous potential for all types of industries. Radio and telecom industries could have accurate maps displaying service areas and signal strength. Verizon could finally get rid of their one-man signal verifier in favor of a legion of receptors atop their vehicles.

Perhaps more intriguing is its application to the built environment. Libraries, cafes, and homes are formed to the boundaries of a Wi-Fi hub. Walls are built to move in sync with signal fluctuations. Groundbreaking ceremonies now include the first powering-on of the hubs. Technology has officially replaced masonry as the new cornerstones of our buildings, its signal our scaffolding. Transcribe the technology to map audible environments and you can determine the volume of space in which the sustained decibel level is above 65. This would be of great interest to residential developers, hospitals and schools, or anyone else that doesn't want to live behind a concrete barrier near a highway or airport.

The technology will have officially permeated our market when it becomes an iPhone app. People hold out their phones like divining rods in search of strong signals. Hi-tech games of hide-and-go-seek with your friends running about the city. A second wave of geocachers search for small beacons hidden in mundane locations. Indeed these experiments have opened up more possibilities than just a graphic for the technology.


What if the technology is attached to brain wave sensors, sold in handy packages over the counter. Instantly your emotions are given a definition and a space; people can measure how sad you are in cubic feet, or literally step inside your "happy place", or know just how far away to stand when you're angry. If an architecture can be made to respond to these readings (possibly with inflatable materials), we could create rooms that are always just the right size-always intimate without being confining. Or in prisons, where the devices are programmed inversely, so the angrier and more dangerous you are, the smaller your cell.